Parental Paranoia Bit me in the Butt Today
A little while back, we had the opportunity to judge Lenore Skenazy's parenting judgment, well it's now your turn to judge me because the cops showed up at my door to check on me and my kids.I think it's all indicative of this paranoia we have as a society where things that were once perfectly acceptable are now horrific things that could cause our children to spontaneously combust if we're not careful. :-( Yes, I exaggerate.
Here's the story (and it's kind of embarrassing for me to share because, no doubt, some people will think I'm terrible for what I did):
After picking the kids up on this rainy day (I slide that in, so you know it wasn't hot out in any way, shape or form), I stopped at a local drug store to get a heating pad to ease the rib pain of this third-trimester pregnant body. The kids asked if they could wait in the car after I clarified with them that I was only in there to buy a heating pad and NOTHING else. Since I could see them from the window, I decided it was fine.
My kids are 5 and 7 and knew exactly where I was and where to find me should they run into trouble. They are perfectly capable, intelligent people who are entitled to a little independence now and then. However, I felt a twinge of guilt as I left them there. Not because I thought anything bad would happen, but because of what others looking into the car might think.
I go into the store. As I'm in line to pay, I see there is a car running in the parking spot beside my car, so I keep an eye on it. A lady is outside her car, pacing back and forth and talking on a cell phone. I pay for my stuff, having some idea what's going on, but not interested in a confrontation. As I come up, the lady goes into her car and closes the door and sits staring at me. I looked at her a couple times, but what the heck am I supposed to say? So I just drive home.
Soon after, there's a knock at our door and a police officer is there. He asks my husband if I'm home. My kids and dogs are running around happily and the cop sees this. I come to the door and am told that someone called 911 because they were concerned about the kids being left in the car. The cop essentially tells me (I paraphrase, of course):
"I really shouldn't be here, but we have to follow-up on complaints. It's not a hot day and obviously, you just ran into the store to grab something."
We talked a bit and I asked if I did break any laws at all and he assured me that I did not. He also said (I don't think he was a parent) that as a kid his mom would do the same thing and that "these days people are so worried about everything." --- Hmmmm...smart man.
He collected more information just so he could close the file or whatever you call it and was on his way.
How I Feel:
I'm not really sure. On the one hand, I'm annoyed that someone would think I was doing something terrible to my children. On the other, I'm kind of glad that there are people who pay attention and do take the time to make sure things are OK.
I also admit that I've seen kids in cars and felt a twinge of concern sometimes too (yes, hypocritical, I know...but I'm a victim of paranoid society too!). But I've always just kept an eye on things and made sure parents came back...not actually felt compelled to call 911.
What Would You Have Done?:
Now, it's your turn...what would you have done from both sides of the fence? Do you ever leave your kids in the car, even if it's just for a few minutes? If you were that woman who saw my kids, would you call 911?
Be as honest as you want. If you think what I did was horrible, please go ahead and say so. Constructive criticism is always welcome in my book.




5 Comments:
Hi Alice,
I don't think I would have called 911. I think the woman overreacted just a bit!
I mean, it's not like we live in the middle of Detroit or Harlem or something...I consider BC still somewhat safe for the most part ;-)
If I were in her shoes and I thought the kids were in any imminent *real* danger, I might have kept an eye on them til you returned...but that's about it.
I don't think you did a bad thing; I think you used your best judgment as a parent in the situation, and you know your kids best.
I've seen my share of bad parents who treat their kids poorly, and you don't even remotely belong in that category.
'Nuff said.
Barb (aka harmonicbarbie ;-)
Hmmm...well, your kids are certainly older than toddlers so I think they are old enough to be left in a car for a few minutes. And, you had two kids in the car instead of one, which seems safer than leaving one in the car to me for some reason.
The 911 thing was overboard. All she really had to do was stand next to the car or sit in her own car and keep track of the situation (something I have actually done myself) and then if she has a concern she can voice it to you directly. Sometimes just having someone say something is enough to make one think about whether what they did was a good idea.
The fact that it wasn't hot (or cold) is a major factor too. No big deal from a weather standpoint in my opinion.
But I feel conflicted about it. The other day, I realized I left an important paper on my coffee table after I had already strapped my son into his car seat in the car parked in the driveway. I started to get out to retrieve the paper and realized that I couldn't because my son was already buckled in and I didn't want to take him out. Even though I knew I would be only ten seconds (literally) I didn't go back in and not because I was worried about his safety....it was because I was worried someone would notice me doing it. I would have locked the car and turned on the alarm for those ten seconds, and the living room looks out on the driveway, but I didn't do it.
So I understand your dilemma....if I had a child 5 and under I would not leave him in a car for even a second. They can mess with stuff in the car and create a dangerous situation. But I don't think you did anything too terrible. :) However, I tend to err on the side of caution and probably wouldn't have, but mostly out of fear of what happened to you today.
But, I *still* have a fear of my kid being out of my sight, so distance plays a role. A store situation, where you might not know how long it will take, would concern me. Getting out to drop something at the post office or something is no big deal.
But every parent has to make that decision for themselves.
Thanks for your thoughts and honesty ladies.
Barb - It was in a nice neighborhood and somewhere I go at night alone all the time without ever a worry.
Jen, I know how you feel and that protectiveness and worry does pass as your baby grows and for practical purposes when you get another. When my first was a baby, we lived in a high rise, so it really sucked if I forgot something cuz I really couldn't leave the baby in the car. If we lived in a house at that time, I probably would have done it.
For the record, and Jen your thoughts made me think of it, if it were just the 5 year old, I would have made him come in. I agree, the fact that there were two often coupled with the fact that my 7 year old is a responsible 7 year old...made the decision feel okay for me.
Funny thing is, the heating pad I bought doesn't even work and it was a wasted trip in the end. Sigh!
I don't know how this will affect my decisions in the future.
When I go to the gas station, I lock the door and always leave the kids in the car when I pay. When they were younger, I'd get them up and then got tired of that so I'd drive right up to the door and pay. Now I just leave the car at the pump where I can still see what's going on.
I also run into check my mailbox, while they are in the car right outside the window.
But the quick shop and watch through the window thing...I don't know how I'll handle it. But what I do know is that if I do stop, it's because of OTHER people and not what I think is okay for my kids.
I've done the same thing Alice.
What I would have done if I was concerned about the kids safety was wait until the Mom got back, then leave. I've done this before.
If it was an infant/toddler, that would have been different. But a 911 call? Please!
I have nightmares about people sticking their nose into my parenting personal business and taking my kids away because we (gasp!) homeschool or (gasp!) cosleep or (gasp!) whatever. If there is no abuse happening, people need to mind their own business.
If I was the person who spotted your children, I'd do the same thing as Carrie, just hang around till mom comes back.
On the flip side, though I've never left my girls to do any shopping. Yes, I am anal like that. Drag them out for every darn thing and yes, I do keep my kids on a tight leash. You betcha I qualify for the paranoid mom award. But... gosh, I dunno, maybe... just maybe it has something to do with the fact I'm raising all girls and because of many years of not so good childhood memories, I feel I have to.
Anyhow, I have left them in our drive way strapped in (as Jen describes) for 10 seconds or so to grab something I forgot, or maybe something they demand they gotta have.
Yes I think the rainy day - weather plays a big part.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home